Once you've viewed the video, discuss on your blogs what you noticed about their responses. You should also consider how you saw the shape and how your perspective compared to the way the students described what they saw.
I found this
video to be very interesting because when I was watching the shape be shown I
had the same response that one little boy had in that “he just remembered the
shape.” I watched the shape and did not
make a connection to it I just remembered the visual of it and knew what to
draw. Many students made connections to
real life objects. Students gave
responses such as: “it looked like a moon”, “it looked like a C”, “it looked
like a banana”, “it looked like a boat”, and “it looked like a melon”. Students were able to look at the shape and
then think of an object it reminded them of; even if it was an object they had
to rotate. The teacher would allow the
students to show her how they related the picture to the object they named by
having them to come to the overhead and maneuver the object to show the rest of
the class. I thought it was neat also
that the one little boy named the shape by its actual name which was a “crescent”. Another thing I found interesting was when he
mentioned that there were two points that helped in drawing the picture one at
the top and one at the bottom with two curved sides. I found that to be interesting as his way of looking
at the picture. It was a neat activity to see to understand how students learn because as I mentioned I just remembered a visual image without anything to compare it with or remember it by and was able to draw it but these students had in depth reasons as to how they remembered the shape. I would like to try this in the classroom just to see the way that my students think about things.
Case Studies: Shapes:
These case studies were very interesting for me to
look at to see the way that the children thought about different things. Looking at Andrea’s case it was a neat way to
watch how the students viewed triangles.
Susannah had a hard time grasping that triangles that don’t look like “real
triangles” (which I took as what appeared as 3 equal sides) could not possibly
be triangles. After hearing suggestions
from different classmates about what a triangle was she finally agreed with one
idea suggested by classmate Will that a triangle can have “two slanty sides”. Evan who was in this case as well seemed to
understand what a triangle was the best to me.
He knew that a triangle had points at their ends and were not
curvy. He also suggested a triangle is
made up of three sides. He shared an
idea with the class that “no matter how you turn him, he is still Evan.” This was interesting to me because it was a
very valid point. A triangle is made up
of three straight sides that connect and no matter how you maneuver it, it
remains a triangle.
Natalie’s case was more to me about definitions and
how they need to be exact. Students were
describing squares and rectangles pretty much as the same thing being: “four
sides, four corners, and it’s a square.”
That is not true not all shapes that fit that description are a
square. A rectangle fits that
description but its parallel sides are the same size. This case showed me the importance of giving
detailed and correct definitions but also made me think that giving visuals
would help students to better understand ideas and concepts.
In looking over Dolores’s and Andrea’s cases it was
evident that the students were talking about how to make sense of a new
idea. The students in Andrea’s case said
something very well when he said “we have to make our eyes and our heads meet.” He suggests that we have to look outside of just
what we already know or what we are seeing and connect the two to have a better
understanding of a concept or idea. In
Delores case study a student suggest that “we have to be open to look further”
which suggest that sometimes the ideas we have are not always right and we have
to keep our minds open to learning new things.
In my classroom I hope to be able to lead my
students in a direction that does not get them confused. I hope to be able to give my students
concrete definitions and examples of terms that they can carry with them
throughout their years. I also want to
be able to teach my students to have an open mind when learning because things
can change and ideas can be elaborated on as well. I myself as the teacher have to keep an open
mind when teaching because I can be introduced to new teaching strategies or
new methods of learning that I am unaware of.
I found these case studies to be a lot of help and very interesting.
For further discussion:
If geometry is the mathematics that describes the world we live in, that means geometry is everywhere around us. Use the language and concepts of geometry to describe your own world your home, your workplace, your possessions, your daily commute or other travels.
As I am laying in bed writing this blog I am going to describe my room using geometrical terms:
- The room is shaped like a SQUARE.
- The mirror is shaped like an OVAL.
- The walls make up 4 RIGHT ANGLES.
- The TV is a RECTANGLE that has 4 RIGHT ANGLES.
- The window has PERPENDICULAR LINE SEGMENTS forming window panes.
- The green chair has INTERSECTING LINE SEGMENTS.
- The desk chair has SPHERE shaped wheels.
- The fan has a 3-D CIRCLE and a 2-D CIRCLE on it.
- The dresser is a RECTANGLE made of smaller RECTANGLES, SQUARES, and CIRCLES.
- The pin board is one big SQUARE made up of 4 smaller SQUARES.
- The bed is a RECTANGLE.
- I am sure there are many more but I wanted to list the major things that stick out to me.


When I saw the shape, I was also just able to remember it to draw it, however I also related it to a moon like one of the students. I guess I kind of related it a little bit and remember a little bit because I thought to myself, of that looks like a moon, then when it was covered, I just drew it. Did you hear the student say it looked like a part of a jet ski? Did you understand what he meant by this? I could not figure it out and wished the teacher had it explain it more. You also mentioned the little boy who was able to say it was a crescent. I was impressed by this. Most first graders do not know this kind of shape name. Were you impressed?
ReplyDeleteI was interested by the fact that students were not able to recognize a triangle as a triangle if it did not have equal sides. I have no seen any students with this same thinking. Have you? What would you do if your students could not see that these were still triangles as well?
I found it interesting that students could not realize that they had used the same definition or squares and rectangles. I also thought it was interesting that the parallelogram was not considered a square even though it has the same definition the students had come up with. If your students are not understanding the difference between attributes and definitions what would you do? Do you think these students are too young to understand these concepts?
It is amazing to see all the geometric shapes and concepts in the real world!
I did hear the student say that it looked like a part of the jet ski and I as well was confused. I thought maybe the shape of the seat how it curves in or maybe the bottom of the jet ski. I am not sure though? I was impressed by the little boy who noticed it was a crescent. I believe he was the same boy who said that he just remembered the picture but responded with it being a crescent whenever she asked the shape. I was surprised to see the students struggling with the triangles. I always new if there was three straight sides that connected it was some sort of a triangle. The students should have been introduced to a definition like that in order to understand the differences among triangles. I almost felt like the students needed a chart that had a picture and then had a definition to go with it that told its exact characteristics. Also, maybe a comparison among shapes would help students realize why certain shapes are what they are. I do not believe the students are too young to understand these concepts because students begin recognizing shapes at a very you age.
ReplyDeleteThe little boy who knew it was a crescent was the boy who said he just remembered the shape. He seemed like a very smart first grader.
ReplyDeleteI also think students should have been introduced to the definition of triangle. Maybe they needed to see examples and nonexamples like we had talked about in the previous module. I feel like for geomtric concepts, examples and nonexamples are almost better than definitions.
Think about how triangles are often presented in environmental print or really any shape...they are all regular. So, our environmental print is actually reinforcing young children's misconceptions about shapes. Most classrooms that contain posters of geometric shapes all have shapes that look the same. Consider making your own posters (ideally with the kids) that shows different types of shapes.
ReplyDelete